Skip to content
Free U.S. shipping on orders of $40 or more

Humidor Not Holding Humidity? 9 Causes and Fixes

Quick answer

Check in this order: the hygrometer (is it even right?), the seal, whether the cedar was seasoned, and the humidifier. Most humidors that "won't hold" either leak at the lid, still have dry cedar soaking up moisture, or use a one-way humidifier that's run dry. Calibrate, test the seal, re-season if needed, and switch to two-way packs sized to the box.

Shop Humidi-Cure® 73%Pack sizing guide

Two-way 73% RH, plant-fiber core, no liquid or gel. U.S. orders of $40 or more ship free.

The nine causes

Cause Sign Fix
1. Wrong hygrometer Reading never changes or disagrees with cigars' feel Salt test or replace with digital
2. Leaky seal Drops fast after every refill Test the seal
3. Unseasoned cedar New humidor, RH sinks for weeks Season it
4. Humidifier ran dry Slow drift down Refill or swap packs
5. Undersized humidification Never reaches target Add packs
6. Overpacked box Uneven, top vs bottom Make room for air
7. Opened constantly Dips after each opening Open less, use a travel case
8. Bad location Swings with the day Away from windows, vents, sun
9. Seasonal air Fine in summer, dry in winter Extra packs in winter

Start with the hygrometer

An analog hygrometer can be 10 points off. Before changing anything, test it. If it's wrong, you may not have a humidity problem at all. See cigar hygrometer guide.

Humidity too high instead?

Above about 75% RH, mold and beetles get interested. One-way humidifiers keep adding water even when the box is full. Two-way packs absorb extra moisture too. See over-humidified cigars.

FAQ

Why does my humidor keep dropping humidity?

Usually a leaky lid, cedar that wasn't seasoned, or a humidifier that's run dry.

How long does a humidor take to stabilize?

A seasoned, sealed humidor usually settles within a day or two of a change.

Should I add water to my humidor?

Never directly. Use a humidifier or two-way packs.

Keep reading: Humidor in a humid climate · Cedar maintenance · Where to put a humidor

Other blogs

Check more

Cart0 item

Your cart is currently empty.

Not sure where to start?
Try these collections: