Skip to content
Free U.S. shipping on orders of $40 or more

Electronic Humidor Humidifiers vs Two-Way Packs: Which for a Large Humidor?

Quick answer

Electronic humidifiers add moisture quickly with a fan and a sensor, which helps large, frequently opened cabinets in dry climates. They can't remove moisture, need power and water, and can fail without warning. Two-way packs need neither, and also absorb excess. Many owners of big cabinets use both: the electronic unit for recovery, packs on each shelf as a buffer.

Shop Humidi-Cure® 73%Pack sizing guide

Two-way 73% RH, plant-fiber core, no liquid or gel. U.S. orders of $40 or more ship free.

Comparison

Electronic Two-way packs
Adds moisture Yes, fast Yes
Removes moisture No Yes
Power Needed None
Water Distilled refills None
Failure mode Sensor drift, empty tank, power cut Spent pack, swap it
Best for Large cabinets, dry climates, heavy use Any size, humid or dry rooms

Using both

  • Set the electronic unit a couple of points below your target
  • Packs on every shelf at 73% do the fine control and absorb overshoot
  • Monitor with an independent hygrometer, not just the unit's sensor

FAQ

Do I need an electronic humidifier?

Only for large cabinets in dry conditions, or with heavy daily opening.

Can an electronic humidifier over-humidify?

If its sensor drifts, yes. Two-way packs help absorb the excess.

How many packs for a cabinet?

Spread them across shelves; about one 8 g per 5 to 6 loose cigars.

Keep reading: Cabinets and wineadors · Packs vs beads vs gel · Hygrometer guide

Other blogs

Check more

Cart0 item

Your cart is currently empty.

Not sure where to start?
Try these collections: